Hong Kong SFC Fines Swiss-Asia Asset Mgmt $382,000 for 225 Risky Options Trade over 15 Months, Breached Client Discretionary Account Trade Parameters
8th November 2022 | Hong Kong
The Hong Kong Securities & Futures Commission has fined Swiss-Asia Asset Management $382,000 (HKD 3 million) for regulatory breaches in monitoring of trading activities in discretionary accounts, allowing 225 risky options trade over a period of 15 months (2015 to 2016) in a client discretionary account. In 2015, the client had signed an asset management mandate agreement granting Swiss-Asia full discretionary power to manage the account, allowing to sell covered call options on existing securities and option strategies which have clear & defined risk, but should not include any option strategies that involved uncapped risk or purchase options as a speculative strategy for the portfolio. In late August 2016, the client had complained to Swiss-Asia that its licensed representative conducted option trading in the Account which was much riskier than agreed. Hong Kong SFC: “The licenced representative of Swiss-Asia placed a total of 869 options trades in the Account. Swiss-Asia only submitted to the SFC in April 2017 that it had identified 225 of these options trades to be outside the Management Restrictions. Swiss-Asia’s lack of monitoring of trading activities resulted in options trades, which it identified to be outside the mandate, being placed by its licenced representative in the Account for a duration of around 15 months.” See below for SFC full investigation.
“ Hong Kong SFC Fines Swiss-Asia Asset Mgmt $382,000 for 225 Risky Options Trade over 15 Months, Breached Client Discretionary Account Trade Parameters for Options “
Ads & Announcements Hong Kong SFC Statement Hong Kong, Asia’s leading financial centre
SFC reprimands and fines Swiss-Asia Asset Management (HK) Limited HKD 3 million for regulatory breaches
8th November 2022 – The Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) has reprimanded and fined Swiss-Asia Asset Management (HK) Limited (Swiss-Asia) HKD 3 million for internal control failings and regulatory breaches in relation to the monitoring of trading activities in discretionary accounts and record keeping (Notes 1 to 6).
The disciplinary action follows an SFC investigation into the internal controls of Swiss-Asia after a client’s complaint. The complaint centred on option trading by a former licensed representative of Swiss-Asia in the client’s discretionary account. The client claimed that some of the trades were much riskier than agreed and fell outside the scope of her asset management mandate agreement with Swiss-Asia between April 2015 and August 2016.
The SFC’s investigation found deficiencies in internal controls of Swiss-Asia, in that it failed to:
- properly monitor the trading activities in the client’s discretionary account for around 15 months;
- have procedures in place to ensure proper supervision of the operation of discretionary accounts; and
- maintain proper records of its compliance checks on discretionary accounts.
In deciding the sanction, the SFC took into account all relevant circumstances, including:
- the duration of Swiss-Asia’s failures;
- Swiss-Asia’s cooperation in resolving the SFC’s concerns; and
- Swiss-Asia’s otherwise clean disciplinary record.
STATEMENT OF DISCIPLINARY ACTION
The Disciplinary Action
(a) properly monitor the trading activities in a client’s discretionary account (Account) from around May 2015 to August 2016 (Relevant Period);
(b) have procedures in place to ensure proper supervision of the operation of discretionary accounts; and
(c) maintain proper records of its compliance checks on discretionary accounts.
Summary of facts and breaches
A. Failure to properly monitor the trading activities in the Account during the Relevant Period
(a) General Principle 2 (diligence) of the Code of Conduct for Persons Licensed by or Registered with the Securities and Futures Commission (Code of Conduct), which requires a licensed person to act with due skill, care and diligence, in the best interests of its clients and the integrity of the market;
(b) paragraph 4.3 (internal control, financial and operational resources) of the Code of Conduct, which requires a licensed person to have internal control procedures and financial and operational capabilities which can be reasonably expected to protect its operations, its clients and other licensed or registered persons from financial loss arising from theft, fraud, and other dishonest acts, professional misconduct or omissions; and
(c) paragraph 2 of Part VII of the Management, Supervision and Internal Control Guidelines for Persons Licensed by or Registered with the SFC (Internal Control Guidelines), which provides, among others, that where the firm exercises discretionary authority over a client’s account, procedures should be used to ensure that only transactions which are consistent with the investment strategies and objectives of the relevant client, are effected on the client’s behalf.
B. Failure to have procedures in place to ensure proper supervision of the operation of discretionary accounts
them. However, the SFC considers such reviews to be inadequate – the options trades which Swiss-Asia identified to be outside the Management Restrictions, and which have been ongoing for around 15 months in the Account, were not detected until the client filed a complaint with Swiss-Asia.
10. Swiss-Asia’s failure summarised in paragraphs 8 and 9 above constitutes a breach of paragraph 7.1(e) of the Code of Conduct, which requires a licensed person to implement internal control procedures to ensure proper supervision of the operation of discretionary accounts.
C. Failure to maintain proper records of its compliance checks on discretionary accounts
Conclusion
(a) the Disciplinary Fining Guidelines made under section 199(1)(a) of the SFO;
(b) Swiss-Asia’s failure to properly monitor the trading activities in the client’s Account for a period of around 15 months;
(c) adequate internal procedures and controls are fundamental to the fitness and properness of a licensed corporation, in particular, those relating to the monitoring of trading activities are important for the detection and prevention of potential market misconduct;
(d) a clear message should be sent to the market on the importance of effective internal controls and procedures;
(e) Swiss-Asia has revised its internal control policies and procedures such that post-trade checks would be conducted on all accounts on a weekly basis, and that any breaches in investment strategies or exceptions in the investment restrictions would be documented and escalated to executive management;
(f) Swiss-Asia’s cooperation in resolving the SFC’s concerns and undertaking to provide the SFC with a report prepared by an independent reviewer within six months confirming that all the identified concerns were properly rectified; and
(g) Swiss-Asia had no previous disciplinary record with the SFC.
2021 Data Release 2020 List of Private Banks in Hong Kong2020 List of Private Banks in Singapore 2020 Top 10 Largest Family Office2020 Top 10 Largest Multi-Family Offices2020 Report: Hong Kong Private Banks & Asset Mgmt - $4.49 Trillion2020 Report: Singapore Asset Mgmt - $3.48 Trillion AUM Register Below Latest 2022 data & reports, insights & news Every Saturday & Sunday 2 pm Direct to your inbox Save 2 to 8 hours per week. Organised for success For Investors | Professionals | Executives New to Caproasia? Join 10,000 + Learn More | Sign Up Today Caproasia.com | Caproasia Access 2022 Events | TFC - Find Services Grow Business | Contact Us For CEOs, Heads, Senior Management, Market Heads, Desk Heads, Financial Professionals, Investment Managers, Asset Managers, Fund Managers, Hedge Funds, Boutique Funds, Analysts, Advisors, Wealth Managers, Private Bankers, Family Offices, Investment Bankers, Private Equity, Institutional Investors, Professional Investors Get Ahead in 60 Seconds. Join 10,000 + Save 2 to 8 hours weekly. Organised for Success. Subscribe / Sign Up / Contact Us Sign Up / Subscribe:
Mailing ListFree TrialInvestor $680 YearlyProfessional $680 YearlyExecutive $2,000 Yearly
Interests / Events / Summits / Roundtables / Networking:
Private WealthFamily OfficePrivate BankingWealth ManagementInvestmentsAlternativesPrivate MarketsCapital MarketsESG & SICEO & EntrepreneursTax, Legal & RisksHNW & UHNWs Insights
Your Name*
Company*
Job Title*
Email 1 (Work / Personal)*
Email 2 (Work / Personal)
Contact No.
Country
Your Message (leave blank if none)
Owl Media Group takes pride in providing social-first platforms which equally benefit and facilitate engagement between businesses and consumers and creating much-needed balance to make conducting business, easier, safer, faster and better. The vision behind every platform in the Owl Media suite is to make lives better and foster a healthy environment in which parties can conduct business efficiently. Facilitating free and fair business relationships is crucial for any thriving economy and Owl Media bridges the gap and open doors for transparent and successful transacting. No advertising funds influence the functionality of our media platforms because we value authenticity and never compromise on quality no matter how lucrative the offers from advertisers may seem.